May 11 2019

SYSK Selects: How Lie Detectors Work

Selects 28 min 4 movies discussed
Listen

Instead of actually detecting lies, polygraph machines sense physiological variations, ostensibly brought on by guilt. The results are subject to interpretation, and therefore controversial. Join Josh and Chuck as they investigate the polygraph.

AI Summary

This episode dives into the fascinating and controversial history of polygraph machines, starting with their invention in the 1920s by a Berkeley cop who used one to solve the first crime ever solved with a lie detector. Josh and Chuck explore how these devices actually work—measuring breathing, heart rate, and sweating—and explain why calling them "lie detectors" drives everyone in the field absolutely crazy since they can't actually detect lies, only physiological responses to stress. The guys break down how polygraphs are administered, their many flaws and false positives, why the federal government is both the biggest user and opponent of them in court, and what newer technologies like brain imaging might eventually replace them.


Movies Discussed

Mr. Show with Bob and David
Mr. Show with Bob and David
1995
★ 7.6
"Go watch the shoe store job interview clip from Mr. Show on YouTube. — Recommended a specific sketch from Mr. Show that humorously deals with lie detectors." — Josh
Saturday Night Live
Saturday Night Live
1975
★ 7.0
"Saturday Night Live had a funny skit that he had gotten a whole group of people to all stick up at once. — Referenced a funny SNL sketch about a congressman yelling 'You lie' in Congress." — Chuck
This American Life
This American Life
2007
★ 8.7
"Just retell episodes of this American Life. — Referenced in a listener suggestion to improve the podcast by retelling This American Life episodes."
Wonder Woman
Wonder Woman
1975 TV-G
★ 7.0
"He's the guy who invented...Wonder Woman, the character? Yes. — Mentioned that William Marston, the polygraph inventor, created the Wonder Woman character." — Josh

💬 Comments

Log in to leave a comment.

No comments yet. Be the first!