← All Episodes

Apr 18 2013

Uses of the Insanity Defense

31 min 1 movie discussed
Listen

The idea that a person who can't understand the crime they've committed is wrong lets them off the hook from culpability for their actions is a longstanding pillar of Western criminal law. Learn about some of the prominent and overlooked cases where the accused has plead insanity in this episode of Stuff You Should Know.

AI Summary

Join Josh and Chuck as they dive into the fascinating and complex world of the insanity defense, exploring how the legal system has grappled with mental illness in criminal cases throughout history. They trace the evolution from England's 16th-century "wild beast test" through famous cases like Daniel M'Naghten's assassination attempt on a British Prime Minister, all the way to modern controversies like John Hinckley Jr.'s attempted assassination of President Reagan. The hosts examine different legal standards, share compelling case studies of both successful and failed insanity pleas, and reveal why this defense is far rarer and more difficult to prove than most people think.


Movies Discussed

The Shawshank Redemption
The Shawshank Redemption
1994 2h 22m
★ 8.7
"Like Shawshank, for instance, although he didn't really kill anyone, but that's what they thought was Tim Robbins had walked in on his wife — Chuck used it as an example of a crime of passion where someone might know their actions are wrong but can't stop themselves." — Chuck

💬 Comments

Log in to leave a comment.

No comments yet. Be the first!