Sep 29 2022

How The Rosenhan Experiment Worked

53 min 3 movies discussed
Listen

In 1973 a study was published in Science where psychologist David Rosenhan revealed he had duped hundreds of psychiatric workers by planting perfectly sane pseudopatients within their hospitals and every last one went unnoticed.

AI Summary

# Stuff You Should Know Episode Summary

In this fascinating dive into one of psychology's most controversial studies, Josh and Chuck explore David Rosenhan's groundbreaking 1973 experiment that challenged the very foundation of psychiatric diagnosis. Rosenhan sent perfectly sane volunteers into psychiatric hospitals claiming to hear voices, and virtually all were admitted and diagnosed with schizophrenia—despite behaving completely normally once inside. What makes this episode truly gripping is the reversal: when a skeptical hospital challenged Rosenhan to send fake patients their way, he sent none, yet the staff flagged dozens of real patients as fakes, proving psychiatry couldn't reliably distinguish sanity from insanity in either direction.


Movies Discussed

One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest
One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest
1975 2h 13m
★ 8.4
"It was a gentleman who was always in trouble with the law, who basically saw a way around going to prison. — Josh compares the plot of One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest to Rosenhan's study, where a sane person enters a mental institution." — Josh
The Princess Bride
The Princess Bride
1987 1h 39m
★ 7.7
"He's like Wallachian and the princess bride all of a sudden. — Chuck compares Rosenhan's deceptive tactics to the cunning character from The Princess Bride." — Chuck
The Simpsons
The Simpsons
1989
★ 8.0
"Mayor Quimby, come on, I know we're all frightened and horny, one of the greatest lines ever on the Simpsons. — Josh references a famous Simpsons quote while discussing federal funding and state responsibility for mental health." — Josh

💬 Comments

Log in to leave a comment.

No comments yet. Be the first!