Sep 17 2025

Short Stuff: Killing a Dead Body

Short Stuff 16 min 4 movies discussed
Listen

If you try to kill someone who was already dead is that a bad thing? Yeah? How bad?

AI Summary

# Stuff You Should Know - Summary

In this episode, Josh and Chuck explore the surprisingly complex legal question of whether you can actually be charged with murdering someone who's already dead. They trace through several real cases including a famous 1975 New York incident and a French case from 1986 to show how courts have grappled with the distinction between murder and attempted murder when dealing with corpses. The guys break down how the concept of legal intent ultimately trumped the idea of legal impossibility, meaning you can't murder a dead body but you absolutely can be convicted of attempted murder if you thought the person was alive when you tried to kill them.


Movies Discussed

Bloodfist VIII: Trained to Kill
Bloodfist VIII: Trained to Kill
1996 1h 25m
★ 4.9
"we'll come back with more talk of boogie nights and hard eight right after this. — Josh mentions this P.T. Anderson film alongside Boogie Nights as topics to discuss after the break." — Josh
Boogie Nights
Boogie Nights
1997 2h 36m
★ 7.6
"we'll come back with more talk of boogie nights and hard eight right after this. — Josh teases returning to discuss P.T. Anderson films including Boogie Nights before a commercial break." — Josh
Magnolia
Magnolia
1999 3h 9m
★ 7.7
"great P.T. Anderson movie from 1999 Magnolia. It is great. — Josh references the film to recall Ricky Jay's performance narrating vignettes, including the Sidney Beringer suicide story." — Josh
There Will Be Blood
There Will Be Blood
2007 2h 38m
★ 8.1
"he was actually in the movie, there will be blood, because I don't know, maybe he did such a good job — Chuck mentions Paul F. Tompkins appeared in this P.T. Anderson film after his Magnolia table reading." — Chuck

💬 Comments

Log in to leave a comment.

No comments yet. Be the first!